Monday, September 21, 2009
Violence in Iron Jawed Angels
I found Iron Jawed Angels to be a shocking, and enlightening movie. I realized after watching it that I really had no idea of the struggles that women went through to obtain the vote. Although the picketing, protests, parades and speeches did not surprise me, I was appalled by the amount of violence and cruelty that Alice Paul and the other women in the movie endured. It was startling for me to realize that not only were these women verbally assaulted, but also physically abused while in prison. I could not believe that the United States treated its citizens in the way that they did, by tossing them violently into prison then by physically forcing food down their throats. The hardest part of the movie for me to watch was when Alice Paul had a tube pushed down her throat and raw egg was poured directly down it into her stomach. This movie provided me with a fresh appreciated for my own ability to vote, and a profound gratitude for what women in the past have gone through to give me this right.
Methods Used by Suffragists (IJA)
Along with the physical methods attempted (the parade, boycotting Wilson, forming their own party, etc), the more effective methods were those intangible. The overall sense that they tried to establish their identity as "not above the law" made them somewhat accessible to less radical stems of political parties. They accepted responsibility for their actions with stoic calm and even in the face of jail and cruelty, they stuck together. Which brings me to the most important aspect of the NWP's mentality--unity. An example of this is when Lucy's tied up by her wrists and the rest of them follow suit. The woman on the horse stayed with them despite it being bad for her health, they appealed to even the lower classes, and even the hunger strike they did together. Finally, the vote to change the amendment was only achieved when NAWSA and NWP worked together in the end.
Iron Jawed Angels Response
Like many people before me- I loved this movie! There were a few parts of the movie that really stood out to me. One thing was the relationship between the different groups of women and to see women fighting women. At a time when it was so important for women to be getting as many people as possible on board with their cause it surprised me to see the hostility between the two groups in the movie. Similarly, the situation with the black women, although she did not play a big role in the movie, it was another form of discrimination against women. Although I see where the NWP was coming from in terms of needing all the support they could get; it still surprised me that women who showed such little fear of rebelling hesitated when it came to fighting for equality between women of all races. Another message that was conveyed throughout the movie was the concept of "patients" not only is that a quality many believe a "proper women" should have, it was also a major road block in the progress of women's rights. There seemed to always be something "more important" than giving women the right to vote. The movie showed this in a lot of different ways but particularly when it came to war. Because the country was at war, should women stop "bothering" the President with something "less important"? That may be a valid question but what I learned from watching the movie is that there will forever be something else going on in the world of politics and women's rights should be just, if not more, crucial than all of those things. "Be patient" is a phrase that should only be used once because eventually it translates to "nothing is ever going to happen." This movie was extreamly powerful and gave a clear picture of how hard they faught for the lives we as women have the privalege of living today.
Iron Jawed Angels
The first wave of suffragettes had to fight for more than just the right to vote. Women of color and lower class women were seen as even lesser than upper class white women. During the first parade, Alice Paul worries that having women of color join the other suffragettes there would be more problems for them later. The woman in that scene tells Alice that the women of color must join in the fight at that time, or white women will get the right to vote, and the women of color would be left behind. Not only were women of color in even more of a disadvantage, but lower class women as well. These groups were seen as even less than women, and they had more to lose. Lower class women risked getting their names blacklisted and denied work anywhere, and women of color had to fight harder to be seen as citizens in general. The film shows three different goups of women (white women, women of color and lower class women), and instead of a single struggle of the same magnitude for all of them, there are different hurdles each must overcome.
Iron Jawed Angels
Iron Jawed Angels was nothing like what I expected; it was one of the best movies I’ve ever seen. Does anyone know how accurate the movie is in portraying what actually happened? I realized when I was watching that I had never really thought about what those women went through. I mean I thought about it, but what I imagined was no where near what the movie depicted; I felt a kind of bizarre appreciation.
One of the parts that didn’t surprise me, but maybe should have, were the issues of race; how black women weren’t really included. (This is most likely because I read about it a while back in our Women: Images etc. book). I’m not saying I agree with the treatment of black women (because I absolutely do not) but I do see where the NAWSA and the NWP were coming from, they needed all the support they could get from women and if that meant they couldn’t include black women it puts them in a very difficult position, especially when the majority of them didn’t agree with this. I don’t know what I would have done if I were in their position.
What I found kind of upsetting was that the only reason Wilson spoke on behalf of women voting, seemingly taking their side, was because the hunger strike and mistreatment of women in the jail leaked to the press and he was at risk for bad publicity. I don’t know enough about this to know if this part of history is accurate but if it is I’m very disappointed that that is how it happened. I suppose I should be happy just in general that it happened at all, but I can’t help but feel let down that after all the work the women’s suffrage movement put it, it was as shallow as bad publicity for the president.
One of the parts that didn’t surprise me, but maybe should have, were the issues of race; how black women weren’t really included. (This is most likely because I read about it a while back in our Women: Images etc. book). I’m not saying I agree with the treatment of black women (because I absolutely do not) but I do see where the NAWSA and the NWP were coming from, they needed all the support they could get from women and if that meant they couldn’t include black women it puts them in a very difficult position, especially when the majority of them didn’t agree with this. I don’t know what I would have done if I were in their position.
What I found kind of upsetting was that the only reason Wilson spoke on behalf of women voting, seemingly taking their side, was because the hunger strike and mistreatment of women in the jail leaked to the press and he was at risk for bad publicity. I don’t know enough about this to know if this part of history is accurate but if it is I’m very disappointed that that is how it happened. I suppose I should be happy just in general that it happened at all, but I can’t help but feel let down that after all the work the women’s suffrage movement put it, it was as shallow as bad publicity for the president.
IJA Response
I was surprised with the relations between different races and ethnicities in Iron Jawed Angels. It seemed that the tension and oppression that occurred within the movement were pushed to the back burner and downplayed. While a Black woman from the Chicago delegation did make a stand against the segregation of Black and White women in the parade, I felt that the impact of joining the parade and the ramifications were likely downplayed. I also found it interesting that most of the working women who joined the movement were treated as equals, although many of them appeared to be immigrants. During the early 19th century immigrants faced wide-spread prejudice and discrimination, and I found it interesting that the women's movement appeared to welcome these women as equals but did not do the same for Black women. I know this movie is about the movement as a whole and not specifically about race, but I thought the impact of race and class on the movement should have been given a little more emphasis. Regardless, I think Iron Jawed Angels is an extremely informative and powerful movie, and a great learning tool for both men and women.
Iron Jawed Angels
This was probably one of the best movies that I have seen in a long time, and I cannot believe how much I learned from it. The issues of race and class were one of the things that surprised me the most. I have always thought that African American women were a part of the suffrage movement as well as white women, but in the movie, there was only one African American woman, and she was only shown about two times. I was very surprised by the part when she explained how her committee wanted to march with the rest of the women, and then came the reply that if they wanted to walk, they had to walk in the back because otherwise another committee would not march. I really liked how the response came, if they were marching as women, or as white women. Along with scenes such as this, the rest of the movie requires an incredible range of emotions, from joy, to sadness, to anger. I had no idea the extents to which anti-suffragists were against suffragists until I saw this movie. Even what I learned in high school wasn't anything compared to this movie. In my mind it had always been just women wearing sashes passing out buttons and fliers. There was no violence against them, or hunger strikes, or picketing the White House in my images of the movement. When I saw what it actually was, I was shocked. Probably, the things that I learned the most from this movie were all the different ways they had of getting the public's attention, and as seen, they worked. When their goal was to make it into the newspaper, they did it, even though 100 people ended up in the hospital. But to them, they had reached a goal. The dedication they had to the movement, especially Alice Paul and Lucy Burns was beyond amazing, something I can't even begin to imagine. Overall, this was one of the best movies that I have ever seen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)