Monday, September 21, 2009

Iron Jawed Angels

I was really looking forward to seeing this Iron Jawed Angels. I didn't have many expectations for it, thinking that it'd be a documentary very similar to what we viewed in class last Thursday. However, reading the synopsis and seeing that actresses I was very familiar with would have leading roles added to my excitement, but also caused me to be a bit inquisitive about the film. Many movies that are based off of books and true stories tend to do a rather bad job of the actual portrayal of events and characters. They add in fictional characters and scenes or even take away important ones. However, I loved Iron Jawed Angels and some of the fiction included in the movie were may favorites parts. Beginning with the Emily Leighton (the senator's wife). Her character and story was one of the most intriguing to me. From the moment she was walking down the street with her daughter and was asked if she'd like to be a volunteer or make a donation to the women's suffrage group, to her writings in her diary, to her husbands visit in jail, I felt a connection to the curiosity involved in the diversity of the many women suffragists. I felt that although Emily was not necessarily a real person there were many women like her, closely related to political figures and believing in the fight for women's rights and wanting to participate in the movement. I did not think Emily was going to fully immerse herself in the movement but was overjoyed when she did. My favorite line of hers was "They are the only reason I am here" (in reference to her two daughters). That line showed both the will, strength and maternal instinct that many feel is not included in the personality of a feminist.

Aside from the Emily Leighton I enjoyed developing more knowledge about just went Alice Paul and hundreds of women endured to gain equal rights. While I learned about the movement from teachers and text books in high school, the topic was only discussed to a certain extent. Images of the women standing through all types of weather outside of the White House and how they were treated in Jail struck me. It affirmed the question I often hear of whether or not images are more intense thought provoking and then text. The one dislike I had about the movie was with the portrayal and viewings of Ida B Wells and her involvement with the movement. While there is a time limit, intentions on showing Alice Paul and Lucy Burn's struggle and efforts, I still feel that Ida's actions, ideas and differences made should have been included more in the film. She was only in one seen at the beginning about the parade and to me that was not enough. However, it did not change how I felt or how much I was impacted by the movie. I loved Ironed Jawed Angels and would recommend it to anyone learning about or interested in the First Wave of Feminism.

Iron Jawed Angels- Strategies Used by Suffragists

In the movie, Iron Jawed Angles, women suffragists, led by feminists and advocates Alice Paul and Lucy Burns, were relentless in their fight to have a constitutional amendment for women to have the right and privilege to vote. Paul and Burns were young feminists’ leaders and united in their approach for the passage of the 19th Amendment. The activists were defiant and fearless, focusing solely on getting the amendment passed; they would not allow anything to stand in their way.

Paul and Burns had been in England and were deeply influenced by the British radical feminist, Emmeline Pankhurst. When they returned to the states to join the fight for women’s equality, they did so with the same radical tactics they had learned in England. This did not go over well with the older, more conservative feminists like Carrie Chapman Catt and Anna Howard Shaw, whose approach was to go state-by-state and build a consensus for each state allow women to vote. This was in stark contrast to Paul and Burn’s strategy. Paul and Burns felt there were no guarantees by going state-by-state; it would take too much time.

While political courage cost Alice a great deal, especially in her relationship with Ben Weissman, she sacrificed and put the cause ahead of him, which was unusual at the time. From planning parades, handing out fliers, speaking in streets, recruiting volunteers, speaking to the President, creating a newspaper, organizing the NWP, campaigning all over the country, picketing in front of the White House, to starting a hunger strike in jail, Alice Paul and other suffragists never gave up and did everything in their power to pass a constitutional amendment so women would have to right to vote.

Responce to Iron Jawed Angles

"Courage in Women is often mistaken for insanity". This is an idea that has followed and constrained women for centuries, and it was a huge hurtle that the suffragists in the movie had to overcome. The belief that women are not capable of any kind of intellectually strenuous activity and are overly prone to hysterics has limited women for centuries, as it has perpetuated the idea that women are simple and weak. The threat of being perceived as unstable has been a tremendously damaging stereotype that women are still trying to overcome in many regards, and it certainly managed to limit what both suffragist organizations where capable of doing, as any over the top behavior was liable to discredit their campaign entirely.
I felt that the most powerful scenes in the mover where those that took place in the jail. It was in these scenes that the physical and mental strength of the women where undeniable and unwavering. The most powerful scenes by far was the scene in the mental ward of the prison when the doctor was questioning Alice Paul about her actions and demanding to explain herself. It is in that scene that here intelligence and personal strength shine through, and she proves that in a moment of extreme pressure, women are in fact capable of keeping their heads. As the doctor tries to coax her into making statements that would bring her sanity into question, she manages to state her case so articulately that she in the end manages to win over the doctor’s opinion.

Iron Jawed Angels

I have to start by saying that the movie was so much better than I thought it was going to be. I was expecting some boring, documentary style film that would drag on with a monotonous narrator and dusty newsclips. Obviously, it was nothing of the sort.
What I found most compelling about the movie was the sub-plot concerning Senator Clayton's wife. It starts with her ignoring the feminist movement, then she volunteers an hour for them, then she donates money, and eventually ends up picketing and going to prison for the suffrage cause. What makes her such a powerul figure to me was that her husband, a senator, did not support the movement in his home or on the senate and even once threatens to divorce her. And yet, she perseveres depsite the fact that the man she loves openly opposes her views. I feel it is one thing to stand up for something you believe in and quite another to stand up for it when your partner is on the other side. can you imagine how hard that would be? What I couldnt understand was how plainly he could see how she felt and still wanted to keep her down by not allowing her to have a vote and therefore to have any rights of her own. I'm pretty sure he came around in the end, but how any man could deny a woman he loves any of the privelages he has, how he could watch her suffer under her oppression and not feel moved to change things is absolutely beyond me. Before this movie I did not fully understand how callously women were treated before they were granted their full rights as citizens.

The New Masculinity

According to the seminar description on "The New Masculinity," Pat Fagan, senior fellow and director of the Family Research Council's Center for Family and Religion, will discuss how "feminism has wreaked havoc on marriage, women, children and men. It is time to redress the disorder it has wrought and that must start with getting the principles and ideals for a new 'masculinism' right."

This quote is from an article on feministing.com that I wanted to bring to peoples attention. Apparently, the FRC believes feminism is ruining families, and the only way to fix this is with masculinity. I personally think this is hilarious- who are these brilliant men who think feminism can be beaten down with masculinity? Don't they realize feminism has been fighting this battle ever since it came into existence? And if you really consider equality between men and women "wreaking havoc" you're out of your mind, and have no place giving speeches to anyone.

Iron Jawed Angels

Though I had learned about the woman's movement for voting rights, I had never heard about it from this context. This was a truly powerful movie about perseverance despite opposition. These women have changed the world and began a movement that still continues today in the fight for equal rights.

What surprised me the most about this film was seeing the reaction of the government and public to the movement. There was resistance as I expected, but I did not realize that the government worked hard to suppress the movement and portray it in a negative way. When the women continued to demonstrate outside the White House even during the war, this showed great strength and determination. However, the government switched this image around and called their demonstrations treason. They came up with any kind of excuse to imprison the women and even tried to get Alice Paul institutionalized for life. I was horrified and moved by the actions they took to silence the women. One of the most disturbing scenes for me was when they were force feeding Alice. Despite the extreme pain she went through she continued to stay strong and continue her hunger strike. She was an amazing source of inspiration to all of the other women who were part of the movement (and especially those who were jailed like she was).

I really enjoyed learning about the movement from the perspective of those on the inside and learning about Alice Paul and Lucy Burns. I feel like these women are not recognized enough for their accomplishments and it was eye-opening for me to learn about them in this way.

Iron Jawed Angels

This movie was nothing like I had expected, I didn’t know anything about it going in and usually movies assigned for a class can feel like a waste of time but this is a movie that I would watch again. I really enjoyed the use of humor especially between Lucy and Alice, it made a very serious subject matter really entertaining, but then I thought maybe that was a method of the filmmaker’s to hold attention by making light of such a serious issue. And then the comedy gets ripped out of the story while the suffragists serve their sentences in the work prison. That section of the film was incredibly moving and really well done, it illustrated in so many different ways their unity, for example when Lucy has her hands cuffed above her head so the rest of the women place their hands above their heads. And I could have interpreted this wrong but I felt as if the suffragists won the female guards over, that Alice and Lucy’s determination and endurance to withstand whatever mistreatment the warden threw their way gained the respect of the guards. I had no idea the physical pain and suffering that these women went through to get them the vote and my vote means so much more to me after seeing this film. I really appreciate the women we saw portrayed and the ones we didn’t for working so tirelessly to get me what I take for granted, but I won’t take it for granted anymore.